Advertisement
Advertisement

Estate left to online scammer in ‘highly unusual’ probate case

The Supreme Court has been asked to decide an application for a grant of probate involving a Hervey Bay octogenarian who left his estate to an online romance scammer.

In what she called a case with “highly unusual circumstances”, Justice Rebecca Treston decided the deceased’s daughter was entitled to a grant of probate as the named executor, and entitled to the residue of the estate as the sole beneficiary, after examining issues centring on the deceased’s relationship with “Stella”.

In her decision delivered on 24 September, Justice Treston said she was satisfied that the appointment of the scammer – purported name Stella Helena Perrin (nee Bennett) – as executor, and the gift to her in the will, both failed.

When the 84-year-old retiree died in Maryborough on Christmas Eve last year, his “wife” Stella had depleted his finances over 13 years to leave his estate with one asset, a small property in Hervey Bay, which itself was the subject of a reverse mortgage.

When they met in 2012, Stella told the deceased that she was born in 1976, that she was a former fashion model in New York from an upper middle-class family, and that she lived in the town of Massena in New York.

“At the time the relationship commenced, Mr Perrin was a 71-year-old pensioner living alone at the Point Vernon property. He had significantly impaired vision, such that he could no longer drive. He had never travelled to New York, and I find had never met Stella,” Justice Treston said.

Advertisement

Stella told the deceased she had received a large inheritance, held in New York by a Zimbabwe-based company, which she could not access until the tax on it was paid. 

She sought the deceased’s financial help and identity information to pay the Internal Revenue Service, promising she would then move to Hervey Bay with the balance of the funds.

In April 2013, the deceased considered that he had married Stella, based on a forged marriage certificate supplied by the scammer.

From then until his death, she extracted various funds from him, including as transfers into accounts in the name of other people, Bitcoin, iTunes gift cards, cash to third parties, and SIM cards or iPhones via mail.

She also obtained the deceased’s credit card information, bank details, myGov account details and identity documents.

In 2014, she told him she had moved to Kuala Lumpur, and become a Malaysian citizen. She then supplied false documents to him to claim she could not access her inheritance due to Malaysian taxes.

The apparently hand-made will from May 2024 appointed Stella Helena Perrin, as the deceased’s “wife”, to be executor and trustee. It listed no physical address for Stella, only that she lived in Kuala Lumpur, and had a contact email.

It listed the deceased’s daughter as executor if Stella could not act in the role, and as the beneficiary of a gift over clause.

Justice Treston said she was satisfied that the document represented the deceased’s last will, and by its terms revoked any earlier wills. She said she accepted that the will was duly executed before, and attested to, by two witnesses, and that there was no evidence that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity.

“There will not, however, be a grant in favour of the first named executor Stella, nor any grant in respect of a disposition in her favour,” she said.

“That is because I am satisfied that Stella is either not a real person or does not exist at all.

“First, there is the, respectfully, highly improbable nature of the match in which a former New York fashion model, then apparently 36, would develop a romantic interest in a 71-year-old divorced pensioner living in Hervey Bay, whom she has never met.

“Amongst other things, respectfully, the photographic evidence does lend weight to that conclusion. “

There was also false documentation provided by Stella in relation to the marriage, including that it had no seal, the bride’s name was misspelled, it referred to Fresno County in New York (when it is in California), and it referred to New York as New York State Republic.

“Most importantly, the solicitors for the applicant have confirmed with the Massena Town Hall in New York, that no certificate of marriage from that date between those persons is registered in New York,” Justice Treston said.

There was also correspondence from the deceased which suggested the two were married by the transfer of signatures sent to the Bureau of Births, Deaths and Marriage Marriages in New York, which cost the deceased $700.

“As I say, I find that it is untrue that any such marriage took place by that method,” Justice Treston said, saying also that there was no evidence that the two had ever met, despite apparently being married for more than a decade.

There was also other evidence including the fact that Stella provided false documentation regarding her purported inheritance; refused to provide identity documents when notified she was a beneficiary, and when the deceased’s bank blocked payments to her; used language which suggested English was not her first language.

“In the circumstances, I conclude that the evidence strongly supports the inference that Stella had perpetuated a romance scam against the deceased,” Justice Treston said.

“I am satisfied and find that Stella is not a real person and never existed for any part of the extraordinary period of over a decade of the supposed relationship. I conclude therefore that her appointment as executor and any gifts to her failed.”

She said however, that the gift over clause of the will operated on the specific contingency that if Stella died before the deceased, the entire estate would go to the deceased’s daughter.

“It can be accepted that that contingency did not occur, but where I have concluded that Stella did not exist, the contingency specified in the gift over clause cannot ever have arisen,” she said.

After considering precedent cases, Justice Treston concluded there was “sufficiently clear language” in the will to show it demonstrated an intention to avoid an intestacy.

She said the inference that the gift over was to take effect if Stella never existed “was in fact ineluctable”.

She said there were facts which supported that conclusion, including that the deceased had actively turned his mind to the gift over only 18 months before his death, and that his communications showed evidence that he had grown suspicious of Stella.

She said that had she not come to that conclusion, she would have made orders severing those parts of the will that had been affected by the deceased’s false assumption of the character or identity of Stella.

Read the decision here.

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search by keyword