Advertisement
Advertisement

Townsville treated to insights from legal luminary

Well-known civil liberties campaigner Terry O'Gorman delivers the 2026 Mayo Lecture at James Cook University in Townsville.

Queensland’s evidence disclosure problems are hiding in plain sight and must be confronted, civil liberties advocate Terry O’Gorman told a Townsville audience last week.

The retired criminal lawyer delivered Police and prosecution disclosure failures are causing miscarriages of justice in Queensland. What is the solution? as the 2026 James Cook University Mayo Lecture, at the university’s Douglas campus on Thursday night.

Mr O’Gorman examined the main Queensland cases dealing with disclosure problems, to explain how failures to disclose evidence undermined fair trials, and the reforms needed to protect the integrity of our justice system.

He spoke about a “no consequences” regime for police who actively withheld evidence that they were legally obliged to pass on to the parties.

“There has to be consequences and accountability for investigating police and prosecutors who fail in their duty of disclosure,” he said.

“This is because the cost to the accused is considerable in terms of wrongly having to serve lengthy jail terms, even if the disclosure failure is eventually remedied, as well as the defendant incurring the considerable costs of running an appeal.

Advertisement

“There should be specific legislation enacted in Queensland that if an appeal is successful because of a disclosure failure, costs should be borne on a full indemnity basis by either the QPS or the DPP.

“Police and prosecutors should be charged with failure to comply with their statutory duty of disclosure under Section 204 of the Criminal Code, namely disobedience to statute law.”

The inaugural Chair of Miscarriages of Justice Australia, which campaigns for a Criminal Cases Review Commission in Australia, outlined defence strategies to ensure adequate disclosure within current system restraints.

He also outlined a path for reform, based on stronger, clearer, and more comprehensive legislative and disciplinary frameworks; mechanisms of accountability; improved training for police and prosecutors; and greater prosecutorial involvement.

The Mayo Lecture is organised by the College of Business, Law, and Governance in collaboration with the James Cook University Law Students Society. The lecture series is held in honour of Marylyn Mayo, a foundational law staff member at JCU. It was supported this year by the Queensland Law Society’s Future Leaders Committee.

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search by keyword