Keywords
Negligence – breach of duty – causation – general duties police officer exposed to traumatic events – officer developed PTSD.
Facts
Mr Lee Caller served as a NSW police officer from 2001 until 2019. Throughout his career he attended numerous traumatic incidents, including fatal motor vehicle accidents, suicides, child deaths, serious child abuse matters and a murder scene involving a burnt and mutilated body. It was accepted that this cumulative exposure caused him to develop PTSD.
A significant event occurred in 2010, known as the “PolAir episode”. This did not involve trauma exposure but rather workplace conflict arising from his refusal to alter a statement concerning a helicopter training incident. Mr Caller suffered stress, anxiety and a mood disorder, took six months off work, and underwent assessment by several medical and psychological practitioners before being cleared to return to operational policing.
Mr Caller sued the State of New South Wales, alleging negligence in failing to:
- adequately educate him and his supervisors about PTSD symptoms;
- implement and maintain systems to record and monitor officers’ exposure to traumatic events; and
- properly assess his psychological fitness before allowing him to return to general duties following the PolAir episode.
The trial judge found a breach of duty in the failure to properly implement systems recording officers’ exposure to traumatic incidents but concluded that this breach did not cause Mr Caller’s PTSD. The claim was dismissed. Mr Caller appealed.
Decision
Leeming JA, Sterm JA, and Ball JA, decision delivered 13 October 2026. Appeal dismissed with costs.
Ratio
The Court upheld the primary judge’s conclusion that, although the police force breached its duty by failing to maintain adequate records of officers’ trauma exposure, that breach did not cause Mr Caller’s psychiatric injury.
The Court also rejected the appellant’s arguments that there had been negligent failures in education, training or psychological assessment and found no error in the trial judge’s reasoning on causation.
The Court accepted that PTSD was foreseeable and that police officers are exposed to significant psychological risks. However, negligence required proof not only of breach of duty but also that the breach caused the injury.
The Court found there was substantial evidence that NSW Police had educated officers about psychological risks and PTSD. Mr Caller himself acknowledged awareness that repeated exposure to traumatic events could cause psychological injury and that counselling services were available. He had also successfully sought medical assistance following the PolAir episode.
The Court rejected the argument that the PolAir episode was a “red flag” demonstrating a heightened vulnerability to PTSD. While it was a significant mental health event, police management responded appropriately by requiring extensive medical and psychological assessments before permitting Mr Caller to return to general duties. All practitioners considered him fit to resume operational work.
On causation, the Court agreed with the trial judge that the appellant’s case depended on a chain of speculation. It was not established that better record-keeping, additional education, or further psychiatric review would have altered any clinical assessment, led to different treatment, or prevented his later PTSD. The professionals who assessed him already knew he had spent many years in general duties policing and had experienced the types of traumatic incidents commonly encountered by police officers.
The Court emphasised that even if the police force had perfectly implemented its monitoring systems, it was not probable that Mr Caller would have been removed from general duties or that his psychiatric outcome would have been different. Accordingly, causation was not proven and therefore the appeal failed.




Share this article