Advertisement
Advertisement

Starting your own firm means making AI decisions

When you set up a practice, you choose a business structure, an insurer, a trust account and practice management software. How you’ll use AI belongs on the same list, and it’s much easier to settle before the first file opens than to unpick later.

At a larger firm, someone else usually decides which AI tools you can use and what can go into them. Once you’re the principal, you make those calls and you answer for them.

Queensland Law Society’s Guidance Statement No. 37, Artificial Intelligence in Legal Practice (GS 37), sets out how the conduct rules apply, and QLS says plainly that it doesn’t seek to discourage AI use or see it as incompatible with ethical duties. Read alongside the Queensland courts’ practice directions, it points to seven decisions a new principal has to make, here in roughly the order you’ll meet them.

1. Choose the plan before you choose the tool

When Clarence checked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot in October, the personal plans of ChatGPT, Claude and Copilot trained on conversations by default unless you opted out, while their business plans said content isn’t used for training by default. None of the four kept personal-plan data in Australia.

The QLS guidance says that if a tool’s terms don’t deal with how your data is used and whether it trains the model, you should avoid the tool, and if the terms are unclear, be very hesitant about giving it confidential information. So the first decision is the plan: a business plan in the firm’s name, set up before anyone uses it on a matter.

2. Decide what client information can go in

Confidentiality and privilege apply to AI tools like anything else. The guidance suggests asking where the provider processes and stores data, who can access it, whether it keeps your inputs or claims rights in the outputs, and whether you can remove identifying details first. It also says information obtained under compulsion generally shouldn’t go into a third-party AI tool unless the owner of that information has been told. A one-line rule is a good start, for example: no client names or identifying details in any tool that isn’t on the firm’s checked business plan.

3. Build checking into how you work

QLS notes that AI can’t be relied on to check its own output, so you check every piece of AI-assisted work yourself. For court work, Supreme Court Practice Direction 5 of 2025 (24 September 2025) puts this in writing. The person named on written submissions must verify the accuracy and relevance of every reference in them, and putting your name on the document tells the Court you’ve done it. A practitioner whose submissions cite material that doesn’t exist may be referred to the Legal Services Commissioner and asked to show cause why a costs order shouldn’t be made against them personally.

The District Court and the Planning and Environment Court have practice directions in identical terms, and the Land Court and QCAT have issued their own on the same subject. File notes are covered as well: QLS Guidance Statement No. 40 says an AI-generated file note should be checked by the practitioner who attended the meeting.

4. Settle what you’ll tell clients and how you’ll bill

QLS says clients should be told when AI will be used where that’s feasible, and the bigger AI’s contribution, the stronger the duty to tell them. Your engagement letter is a natural place to do it.

On costs, GS 37 treats due diligence and licence fees as practice overheads, generally not something to bill. Time spent prompting and checking AI output on a specific matter can be billed on a time basis, but entries have to be accurate, and under time billing the time saved belongs to the client. Fixed fees may suit AI-heavy work as long as the fee is still fair and reasonable, and per-matter AI fees can be a disbursement if your costs agreement can define them that way. All of this is easier to write into your first costs agreement than to retrofit. QLS also has a template warning for clients about their own use of AI tools with confidential information.

5. Ask your insurer before you rely on it

QLS recommends checking with your professional indemnity insurer that the way you plan to use AI is covered, and it points Lexon-insured practices to Lexon’s AI risk analysis. It also reminds principals that the firm usually stays responsible for errors, even when a vendor’s system caused them. Setting up your cover is the natural time to ask.

6. Check the AI in software you’re already buying

Many practice management systems and office suites now include AI features. When Clarence checked in October, Claude was switched on inside Microsoft’s Copilot by default for business customers in Australia. As you set up each account, look at the AI settings as carefully as the billing settings. GS 37 also warns that AI providers can be unstable, so know what you’d do if a tool you rely on disappeared.

7. Write it down, even if you’re the only one in the firm

QLS has an AI use policy template, and in February 2026 it released an AI selection and checklist jointly with six other law societies. A one-page policy covering the tools and plans you’ve approved, what data can go in, how output gets checked and what clients are told is enough to start. QLS notes that having regard to its guidance may make it easier to account for your actions if a complaint is later made to the Legal Services Commission, and a written policy is the simplest record that you did.

Where to read next

For what those four tools do with what you type, Part 1 of Clarence’s Read the Fine Print on AI series covers who owns each one and what happens to your data, checked against each provider’s own sources on 15 October.

For the rest of the setup list, Clarence’s guide to starting your own law practice covers practising certificates, business structure, costs, insurance, trust accounts and your first 90 days.

This article is general information only and isn’t legal or ethics advice. Guidance and providers’ terms change, so check the current versions before relying on them. The QLS Ethics and Practice Centre can help with specific ethical queries.

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search by keyword