A Coroner has called for the establishment of an online gambling regulator after finding that online sports betting led to a young man’s suicide.
In his 101-page report delivered on 20 October, Victorian Coroner Paul Lawrie found online gambling by 22-year-old Kyle Glynn Hudson “was the direct and paramount causative factor underlying his decision to take his own life” in July 2021.
Coroner Lawrie’s inquest into the Werribee university student’s death exposed glaring gaps in the regulation of the conduct of online betting companies.
Mr Hudson had an account with each of five betting companies: Sportsbet, Ladbrokes, Neds, Bookmaker and bet365. He opened the Sportsbet account on his 18th birthday, and the other four the following year. He also had nine other betting accounts but with comparatively limited transactions.
“For a little over four years between his 18th birthday and his death, Kyle gambled prodigiously using these accounts,” Coroner Lawrie said.
“He placed 8585 bets for a total value of $895,733. This resulted in a net loss of $47,945. To maintain his online gambling activity, Kyle deposited a total of $406,725 over 1245 separate occasions.”
Coroner Lawrie found the betting companies’ “safer gambling tools”, employed to monitor a customer’s account activity, provided an incomplete picture of the activity, were blind to a customer’s complete financial situation, and had warning parameters that were inconsistent between them.
“Effectively, all a customer has to do is assert that they have the financial means to support their gambling pattern,” he said.
He said about 85 per cent of Mr Hudson’s betting activity was with Sportsbet, and the gambler had triggered a “safer gambling response” from the company 37 times.
“The implication is that Sportsbet was entitled to rely on untested assurances as evidence which answered, or largely answered, the question whether Kyle was engaged in problem gambling,” he said
“Very few enterprises in the commercial world assess risk in this way … all the risk lay with Kyle, not with Sportsbet.”
The proposed regulator would be responsible for licensing of online betting companies; oversight of a national data vault; the introduction of evidence-based criteria to identify potentially harmful gambling activity; the establishment of a limit-monitoring system across a person’s total gambling activity; and the enforcement of the obligations of online betting companies.
Coroner Lawrie said each state and territory had its own regulatory framework but “the offerings of an online betting company are the same to all its customers, wherever they may be in Australia”.
“An online betting company, as a licensee, should be subject to a regulatory body that has jurisdiction over all its activity in Australia, and which is resourced in a manner commensurate with the size and influence of the industry,” he said.
The regulator recommendation was one of nine made by the Coroner. They also included protections for account holders, such as a ban on bonus offers and inducements; and further restrictions on gambling advertising.
Coroner Lawrie said a national data vault was needed to address a paucity of independent research into online gambling.
“Despite the availability of expert evidence in this inquest, there was a notable scarcity of published research concerning many issues under inquiry,” he said.
“These issues included, for example: the particular vulnerabilities of young men in the context of online gambling; the effectiveness of communications to prompt re-evaluation of personal gambling behaviour; and the effectiveness of ‘safer gambling’ tools.”
Over four years, Mr Hudson redeemed 489 inducements across all the betting companies, valued at $21,696. These inducements included deposit matches, bonus bets, and bet return promotions.
“This is the picture that tells the story,” Coroner Lawrie said.
“There can be little doubt that the availability of promotional offers and inducements, across all the betting companies, must have catalysed Kyle’s betting behaviour.
“Moreover, these inducements must have a contrary and corrosive impact upon the efficacy of the betting companies’ ‘safer gambling’ programs.”
As to the characterisation of Mr Hudson’s gambling behaviour, Sportsbet’s overarching contention was that he “was a reasonably sophisticated gambler who was doing reasonably well and appeared to be consistent and in control”.
“This is troubling to say the least,” Coroner Lawrie said.
In his closing remarks, he said online gambling products were carefully designed to keep gamblers engaged and active, and to extract net losses over time.
“They are dangerous and capable of causing misery and great harm, especially for the young or those whose traits may make them more vulnerable,” he said
He pointed out that Mr Hudson had no history of mental illness, no substance abuse issues, a large circle of friends who played sport together regularly, was in the fourth year of university degree, was in a seven-year relationship, and had a casual job.
“Kyle was a young man brimming with promise, and his story is heartbreaking … Ultimately, he lost everything,” he said.
“Kyle’s case reveals, in the sharpest relief, the human cost of online gambling. It should be a clear signal that we cannot leave monitoring and intervention solely in the hands of the betting companies who, in any event, do not have the whole picture.
“It makes no sense to have differing ‘safer gambling’ tools and thresholds for intervention, depending upon the particular betting company.
“It also makes no sense to pretend that these tools are likely to be effective, even though a person may have a clutch of online accounts with different betting companies and be subject to the persistent confounding influences of advertising and promotional offers.
“These are such critical and obvious deficiencies that the status quo cannot be justified.”
Read the inquest report here.




Share this article